[gcs-pcs-list] call to vote: table the URI debate

[Binkley, Peter]

+1

Peter Binkley
Digital Initiatives Technology Librarian
Information Technology Services
4-30 Cameron Library
University of Alberta Libraries
Edmonton, Alberta
Canada T6G 2J8
Phone: (780) 492-3743
Fax: (780) 492-9243
e-mail: peter.binkley at ualberta.ca


-----Original Message-----
From: gcs-pcs-list-bounces at cipolo.med.yale.edu
[mailto:gcs-pcs-list-bounces at cipolo.med.yale.edu] On Behalf Of Daniel
Chudnov
Sent: Wednesday, March 01, 2006 2:45 PM
To: gcs-pcs-list at cipolo.med.yale.edu
Subject: [gcs-pcs-list] call to vote: table the URI debate

We could keep debating the URI vs. not-URI thing for another two weeks,
but then we'd stay distracted from addressing other pressing issues in
the meantime.  So:

SEEING AS many of us are keenly interested in resolving (he-heh... I
said
"resolving") this debate, and;

SEEING AS there are many other issues to address that are arguably far
simpler and, thus, more likely to be quickly resolved (heh), and;

SEEING AS we all want to keep pushing forward, and;

SEEING AS many of us have previously gone 15 rounds of heavyweight
slugging with the identifier demon before and lived to swear vilely
about it, but;

SEEING AS ALSO how important this is to be sure we decide on before
we're
done;

BE IT PROPOSED that we should table the identifier debate until after
the
next revision or after such time has passed that a number of interesting
new unAPI-driven applications make it easier to weigh the options based
on real code and not our hard-won (or, in my case, lost) biases, and;

BE IT DECIDED that we will leave the spec unchanged, for now, on the
topic of what we mean by "URI" and "identifier", but;

LET IT NOT BE FORGOTTEN that this is of critical importance and to be
taken up again soon, as so stated in the previous-by-two paragraph.

What say?

  -Dan


-- 
Daniel Chudnov
Yale Center for Medical Informatics
(203) 737-5789
_______________________________________________
gcs-pcs-list mailing list
gcs-pcs-list at cipolo.med.yale.edu
http://cipolo.med.yale.edu/mailman/listinfo/gcs-pcs-list